Melamine vs. Polycarbonate: The Ultimate Guide to Tableware
What is Melamine Tableware?
Melamine is a type of high-quality, strong plastic that is widely used in professional kitchens, restaurants, and catering businesses. It is made by combining melamine resin with strengthening materials to create a tough, lightweight alternative to traditional ceramics. One of melamine's biggest appeals is it's ability to mimic the appearance of porcelain or stoneware while being significantly more resistant to damage.
Pros of Melamine:
Highly resistant to chipping, cracking, and breaking, making it perfect for busy kitchens and outdoor dining
Lightweight yet sturdy, making it easy for servers to handle and transport
Retains heat well, helping to keep food warm for longer while ensuring the plate itself doesn't become too hot to touch
Dishwasher safe and easy to clean, reducing labour time and maintenance costs
Availability in a wide range of colours, patterns, and designs, allowing for an upscale, ceramic-like presentation without the fragility
Cons of Melamine:
Melamine cannot be recycled. Melamine is a type of plastic resin that is hardened by a chemical process, making it difficult to break down
Not suitable for use in microwaves or ovens, as high heat can cause it to weaken or warp over time
Can scratch over time with heavy use, particularly when used with metal utensils
Can absorb stains from acidic foods if not properly maintained
What is Polycarbonate Tableware?
Polycarbonate is a virtually unbreakable plastic material known for it's impact resistance and clarity. It is commonly used for drinkware, trays, plates, and food storage containers, particularly in environments where safety and durability are vital. Unlike melamine, polycarbonate is more flexible and can withstand a greater range of temperatures, making it a versatile option for high-volume food service operations.
Pros of polycarbonate:
Polycarbonate is recyclable. It is classified as a thermoplastic, meaning it can be melted down and reshaped multiple times without significantly degrading its properties Exceptionally tough and shatterproof, reducing the risk of breakage and ensuring a longer lifespan
Heat resistant, making it suitable for microwave use
Dishwasher safe and resistant to staining and odours, making it ideal for frequent use in busy kitchens
Transparent options available, mimicking the look of glassware while being for safe for high-traffic environments
Resistant to chemical damage, ensuring longevity even with frequent exposure to detergents and sanitising solutions
Cons of Polycarbonate:
Recycling polycarbonate can be challenging because it is not always accepted at local council recycling services
Can develop scratches over time, which may affect its clarity and aesthetic appeal
Some polycarbonate products may contain BPA, so always check for BPA-free options to ensure safety
Can be slightly heavier than melamine, which may impact ease of use in high-volume settings
Melamine vs Polycarbonate: Which One Should You Choose?
The choice between melamine and polycarbonate ultimately depends on your specific needs and priorities:
If you're looking for elegant, ceramic -like tableware with excellent longevity and visual appeal, melamine is the way to go
If you need ultra-tough, shatterproof options, especially for drinkware, high-impact areas, or self-service environments then polycarbonate is the best choice
If your business relied on microwavable tableware, polycarbonate is preferable due to its heat resistance If presentation is a top priority and you want to maintain a more traditional, high-end dining aesthetic, melamine provides a superior appearance
Final Thoughts:
Both melamine and polycarbonate are excellent investments for catering and hospitality businesses, offering ease of use, and long-lasting performance. The right choice depends on your specific operational requirements, whether that's break resistance, heat tolerance, or aesthetic appeal. At Russums, we stock a wide range of melamine and polycarbonate tableware to suit all catering needs. Browse our selection today and find the perfect solution for your business!
4 February 2025